Prefer fewer words and more pictures? Check out the Instagram!

Who is smarter - boys or girls? 😉

What science knows about sex differences in dogs' cognitive abilities. 

In 2011, TIME ran a news item with a headline that practically begged to be framed: "It looks like there's a reason why Lassie was smarter than Old Yeller. (It's called science.)"
Lassie, in case you've somehow missed the last eighty years, is the collie heroine of the TV show I grew up with, the dog who turned up in film after film to save the day, led the grown-ups to whoever was in trouble, and generally thought faster than anyone else on screen. Old Yeller is the big yellow dog from the 1957 Disney movie (yes, that one; sorry about the lump in your throat). For our purposes, only one thing matters: Lassie is a girl, and Old Yeller is a boy.

Illustration

The ball that broke the laws of physics

The headline was inspired by a new paper from Corsin Müller and his colleagues at the University of Vienna. They invited 50 ordinary pet dogs into the lab, 25 boys and 25 girls, and showed each of them a little magic trick.

Illustration

Concept illustration

First, each dog got to play with two balls: a blue tennis ball and its supersized twin, roughly the size of a cantaloupe. Then she was seated in front of a long wooden runway with a screen in the middle. Her caregiver sat down, held the dog between their knees, and… put on a blindfold. 
A ball rolled slowly along a rail and disappeared behind the screen. An experimenter hidden behind a partition pulled it with a nearly invisible string. And out the other side rolled… a ball of a different size! Small went in, big came out. Or the other way around. For comparison, other dogs saw the honest version: the same ball went in and came out.

Why does this matter? Because that's not how the world works. Things don't grow or shrink while nobody's looking. We rarely think about this bit of knowledge, but we all have it, and we get it early: babies in their first year of life already stare longer at something physically impossible. Researchers borrowed this trick, "looks longer means surprised," from developmental psychologists.

Adults do exactly the same thing. Imagine putting your keys in your bag and pulling out a set twice as big. You won't keep rummaging for your phone. You'll freeze and stare at the keys, or start checking whether your Hogwarts letter has finally arrived.
The girls froze. Females who saw the ball change size stared at it noticeably longer than females who saw the ball stay the same size. The boys didn't seem to care: shape-shifting ball or not, they looked at it for about the same amount of time. Spaying and neutering made no difference for either sex (Müller et al., 2011).
TIME put two and two together: the girls caught the trick, the boys didn't, so Lassie earned her title fair and square. The writers couldn't resist a joke, either: given the male brain's well-known preoccupation with size, they figured, the boys surely would have cared, if only they had been able to notice.
Neat. Simple, clear, and flattering to roughly half the readership. But is it really that simple?

For starters, Müller himself drew no such conclusion. He told reporters there were at least two possibilities. Maybe males really don't notice the switch. Or maybe they notice just fine and don't care: there's a ball, it's rolling, soon it'll be catchable, and its size is beside the point. "Didn't notice" and "didn't think it mattered" are very different diagnoses, and we all know people who fit the second one.

Müller also predicted that if researchers kept looking for sex differences, the scales would tip both ways: for every task where one sex does better, there would be another where the other sex comes out ahead.

And there's a detail that's easy to miss. Each dog saw the trick exactly once. One ball, one look, one try. Picture a circus where intelligence is judged by your first reaction to a magic trick: whoever gasps is the smart one. Anyone who happened to be scanning the crowd for the popcorn vendor at that moment would be doomed.

But that's not even the main problem. Is noticing that the world just broke the laws of physics a sign of intelligence? To some extent, yes, but it's a very small slice of it. Intelligence isn't a single volume knob you can crank up to max. Memory, attention, the ability to hold back an impulse, an understanding of how the physical world works, the knack for "reading" a person or another dog: these are all different abilities, and the same dog can be brilliant at some and hopeless at others. If you have a border collie who learned the names of all five hundred of her toys in a week but still can't walk calmly past a pigeon, you know exactly what I mean.

That's why scientists who seriously study differences between canine boys and girls don't ask "who's smarter?" They ask a humbler question: who does better at this particular task, and how? Task by task, study by study, it turns into a long match where the score keeps changing.

Let's watch the rest of the game. The next goal was scored in Finland.

Cylinders and boxes

In 2021, Saara Junttila and her colleagues published a study with a sample other labs can only dream of: 1,032 dogs from 131 breeds. In behavioral science, where two or three dozen dogs is a perfectly normal sample, that's practically a census.
The first task is a classic that researchers love: a transparent cylinder with a treat inside. I've glued one together myself for experiments in our Human-Animal Interaction Lab at Oregon State University, so I can vouch that it looks completely innocent. The catch is that the treat is perfectly visible through the wall. And if you've ever watched a dog try to walk through a glass door, you have a pretty good idea of what happens next. To get the treat, the dog has to do something nearly impossible for a hungry creature: stop pushing toward the spot where she can see the food and go around to the open end.

Illustration

Junttila, Huohvanainen & Tiira (2021), Animals, Fig. 1 · Source · CC BY 4.0

The girls succeeded on 77% of trials, the boys on 70% (Junttila et al., 2021). Roughly eight out of ten versus seven out of ten. Not a big gap, but a statistically significant one. Another point for the girls.
In the second task, each dog was shown a treat in a box that could not be opened. At all. Not with a paw, not with teeth, not by the power of thought. What matters here isn't the outcome (as you might guess, everyone scored a big fat zero) but what the dog does once she realizes she's stuck. The boys kept working on the box on their own for longer. The girls more often turned to a human, as if to say: this thing is broken, maybe you can figure it out?

Illustration
Illustration
Illustration

Junttila, Huohvanainen & Tiira (2021), Animals, Fig. 1 · Source · CC BY 4.0

And this is where the scoreboard freezes. Who gets the point? You could argue the girls are smarter: why struggle with a box when there's a primate standing right there, with opposable thumbs and an obvious talent for opening things? Or you could argue the boys are more persistent, and persistence is a great quality when a problem can actually be solved. Besides, a glance at a person doesn't prove the dog is asking for help. She might be looking for a hint, getting frustrated, or simply turning her attention to something else. Unfortunately, we can't ask her.
To sort this out, we need a box that can actually be opened.

The box that opens

Charlotte Duranton and her colleagues in Paris gave dogs exactly that. Forty-seven pet dogs from 28 breeds, split almost evenly between girls and boys, came into a small, quiet room with their caregivers. The experimenter let each dog sniff some meat (ground beef and boiled chicken, a serious motivator), then, with big, almost theatrical gestures, placed it in a little wooden box and closed it with a plastic lid that had a handle. The lid could be pulled off with teeth or a paw.
Meanwhile, the caregivers were told to impersonate furniture: stand perfectly still, keep quiet, and don't look at the dog. Oh, and wear dark glasses, just in case, so they couldn't give anything away even with their eyes. Dog cognition research apparently has an unwritten rule: first, blind the human. Vienna went with a blindfold, Paris with sunglasses.

The dogs had two minutes for the first attempt. And finally the boys scored, decisively: they succeeded more often and faster. Had TIME been running the study, they'd have had to come up with a headline about Old Yeller's revenge.

But the experiment kept going. Each dog got two more attempts in a row, and on the second and third attempts, the researchers compared only dogs who had already opened the box at least once. And the picture flipped: now more girls than boys succeeded (Duranton et al., 2015). The boys had the edge on their first encounter with the box. The girls were better at repeating a solution they'd already found.In Vienna, each dog got one try. In Paris, they got three, and the lead changed hands mid-game.
So what counts as smart? Figuring out fast what to do with an unfamiliar gadget? Or remembering what worked and repeating it without any fuss? Life calls for both. One person is the first to crack a new childproof cap; another opens it without looking every time after that. Which one is smarter?

Illustration

Concept illustration

The authors cautiously suggest the boys may simply be bolder with unfamiliar objects. It doesn't seem to be about interest: both sexes approached the box equally fast. The girls, meanwhile, may be better at remembering a solution that worked. But their main conclusion reads almost like a warning to the whole field: which sex comes out ahead can change if you simply give the dog one more try.

The ball comes back

The boys scored their next goal in Italy, in what may be the most elegant episode of the whole match.
Claudia Fugazza and her colleagues in Padua wanted to know how dogs remember a location when they learn it not on their own but by watching a person. That called for dogs trained in Do As I Do: a person demonstrates an action, says "Do it!", and the dog copies it. (Tyrone and I love this game, so I have a pretty good idea how much patience went into the prep.) Just gathering 16 such participants, eight girls and eight boys, was a small feat in itself.

The experiment played out like a little detective story. Two identical blue mats lay about 13 feet apart in a fenced outdoor area, with a couple of hard-to-miss landmarks nearby: a plastic chair and an open beach umbrella. The caregiver walked over to one mat and touched it. Then they led the dog behind a screen, came back, and touched the other mat in exactly the same way, so scent wouldn't give anything away. A little over a minute later, the dog was brought back, but now dog and human stood in the same spots facing the opposite way. The mat that had been on the dog's right during the demonstration was now on her left.

Which way to go? To the mat in the same place relative to the chair and umbrella? Or to the one you reach by making the same turn? Fifteen of the 16 dogs chose the first option and navigated by the objects around them. Scientists call this allocentric navigation: "left of the window," "right of that weird smelly thing in the corner." Its opposite is egocentric navigation: "left of me," "right of me." (And no, it has nothing to do with dogs who think they're the center of the universe.)
So the researchers got sneaky. While the dog waited behind the screen, they rotated the whole setup a quarter turn, and the chair and umbrella stopped being any help. Now only "the same turn" was correct. Every dog got there, and none needed more than 13 trials. But the boys typically needed three or four, while the girls needed nine (Fugazza et al., 2017).

To explain the result, the authors bring up… the Vienna ball. Girls seem to pay closer attention to what they see and hold on more tightly to prominent visual landmarks. In Vienna, that helped them catch the switch. In Padua, the very same trait made it harder to let go of the landmarks once they'd become useless. If that hunch is right, the same tendency looks like intelligence in Vienna and stubbornness in Padua. There were only 16 dogs, though, so it's a lovely hypothesis, not a settled conclusion.
By now the score is hopelessly tangled. Time to stop asking "who" and start asking "why."

Why do they play this way?

To answer that, we have to rewind the tape: to the second before the attempt, then to the hormones circulating in an adult dog's blood right now, then further back to the first months of her life, and finally thousands of years back.
In the second before an attempt, a dog isn't taking an abstract IQ test. She's deciding whether this weird box is worth messing with at all, how badly she wants the chicken, and whether the thing bites. Boldness, motivation, and curiosity aren't intelligence in themselves, but without them, a dog's smarts never even get a chance to show. Maybe that's part of why the Paris boys got off to such a strong start.
Rewind a little further, to hormones. It's a logical hypothesis: if there are differences, maybe sex hormones are behind them? Yet in Vienna, Finland, and Paris, spayed and neutered dogs didn't differ from intact ones. In the mazes, though, spaying suddenly mattered, and only for the girls. In a T-shaped maze, intact females learned the way to their caregiver fastest, and two weeks later every single one of them still remembered it (Mongillo et al., 2017). In a plus-shaped maze, 12 of 14 spayed females preferred to navigate relative to their own bodies, that is, egocentrically (Scandurra et al., 2018). So the question "does spaying matter?" comes down to "for what, exactly?"
Further back still, into puppyhood. The Vienna team itself thought the explanation most likely lay in how sex hormones shape the brain early in life. That could help explain why spaying or neutering didn't seem to matter in some of those adult-dog experiments.

Claudia Pinelli and her colleagues in Naples decided to see how very young dogs handle a similar puzzle. They invited puppies three to six months old, well before puberty (three of the 77 never got interested in the treats, so 74 were tested). Each got an ordinary store-bought puzzle toy with six compartments hidden under lids, cones, and sliders. Only five could be opened, because one hinge was broken (science, as we know, gets done with whatever equipment is on hand). The caregiver and a stranger stood in the room and did their best to pretend they weren't there, even when a puppy looked up at them with a silent question.
The boys typically opened the first compartment in about ten seconds; the girls took around twenty. But by the end of the two minutes, the score had evened out, usually at two compartments each. The girls, though, looked back at the people sooner and more often (Pinelli et al., 2023). 

Illustration

Screenshot of the experimental setup. Pinelli et al. (2023), Fig. 1

The paper's title says it all: "Quick males and social females." Sound familiar? It's the Finnish storyline all over again, only in puppies who are still a long way from puberty.
And finally, thousands of years back, to evolution. This is the most tempting level of explanation and the most slippery one. The Padua team cautiously suggests that flexible navigation pays off for males, who need to find mates quickly. The Vienna team, on the other hand, considered that kind of explanation unlikely: in dogs' ancestors, males and females probably didn't live such different lives. Two teams, two answers, at least until somebody invents a time machine. And that's fine: in science, "we don't know yet" is a result too.

Solo or together

Step back from the scoreboard and look at the whole game, and you see two ways a dog can tackle a problem. She can keep at it herself, trying again and again. Or she can look back at the human. Dogs of both sexes do both. In these experiments, boys on average tended to keep working on their own, while girls were more likely to look back at a person. But "on average" is doing a lot of work here: it's a tendency, not a personality, and as Paris and Padua showed, it can play out very differently on the next task. Both strategies make sense. The only question is what kind of problem the dog is facing.

The puppy study had one more detail: the more often a puppy got distracted by the people, the fewer compartments she opened, regardless of sex. Which is cause and which is effect isn't clear yet: maybe looking at people ate up time, or maybe the puppies who were struggling anyway looked around more. Still, it seems the same habit can get in the way on a solvable task and be a perfectly sensible move on an unsolvable one: that box isn't opening anyway.
So what does this mean for you and your dog?

First, if your dog looks back at you during a hard task, that's no reason to think she's dumb or helpless. She may be looking for a hint, asking for help, or just checking that you're still there. Either way, she remembers there's a primate with opposable thumbs in the room. Sometimes it's worth answering.

Second, if your dog keeps trying on her own, give her a little time before you rush in to help. She may be just about to figure it out.
Third, don't judge a dog by her first attempt, whether in training or when choosing a puppy. Paris showed that a second try can turn everything upside down.

So who's smarter after all?!

Averages are still just averages. On each team you'll find boys with iron self-control at the cylinder and girls who'll keep at a box long after everyone else has given up. Breed, experience, training, the dog's relationship with her person, whether she slept well last night: all of it shows up in the results too. We see the same thing in stress research, where individual differences in hormone levels easily swamp differences by sex, age, or breed.
So picking a puppy by sex in hopes of getting a genius is about as reliable as picking a husband by his zodiac sign. It's far more interesting to figure out how your own dog learns: what motivates her, how she handles surprises, whether she likes to work things out on her own, and when she'd rather call you in.
And Lassie? TIME, you'll recall, handed her the win for being a girl. But one small detail would have spoiled the whole headline: the smart, quick-witted, charming Lassie of all the classic films was played by… boys! First a collie named Pal, then his descendants (Conradt, 2024). And they did just fine.

Sources:
Conradt, S. (2024, August 6). Whatever happened to Lassie (and 8 other showbiz dogs)? Mental Floss. https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/28886/whatever-happened-lassie-and-8-other-showbiz-dogs
Duranton, C., Rödel, H. G., Bedossa, T., & Belkhir, S. (2015). Inverse sex effects on performance of domestic dogs (Canis familiaris) in a repeated problem-solving task. Journal of Comparative Psychology, 129(1), 84–87. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0037825
Fugazza, C., Mongillo, P., & Marinelli, L. (2017). Sex differences in dogs' social learning of spatial information. Animal Cognition, 20, 789–794. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10071-017-1099-1
Junttila, S., Huohvanainen, S., & Tiira, K. (2021). Effect of sex and reproductive status on inhibitory control and social cognition in the domestic dog (Canis familiaris). Animals, 11(8), 2448. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani11082448
Mongillo, P., Scandurra, A., D'Aniello, B., & Marinelli, L. (2017). Effect of sex and gonadectomy on dogs' spatial performance. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 191, 84–89. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applanim.2017.01.017
Müller, C. A., Mayer, C., Dörrenberg, S., Huber, L., & Range, F. (2011). Female but not male dogs respond to a size constancy violation. Biology Letters, 7(5), 689–691. https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2011.0287
Ocklenburg, S., Isparta, S., Peterburs, J., & Papadatou-Pastou, M. (2019). Paw preferences in cats and dogs: Meta-analysis. Laterality: Asymmetries of Body, Brain and Cognition, 24(6), 647–677. https://doi.org/10.1080/1357650X.2019.1578228
Pinelli, C., Scandurra, A., Di Lucrezia, A., Aria, M., Semin, G. R., et al. (2023). Puppies in the problem-solving paradigm: Quick males and social females. Animal Cognition, 26(3), 791–797. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10071-022-01714-5
Scandurra, A., Alterisio, A., Di Cosmo, A., & D'Aniello, B. (2018). Behavioral and perceptual differences between sexes in dogs: An overview. Animals, 8(9), 151. https://doi.org/10.3390/ani8090151
Scandurra, A., Marinelli, L., Lõoke, M., D'Aniello, B., & Mongillo, P. (2018). The effect of age, sex and gonadectomy on dogs' use of spatial navigation strategies. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 205, 89–97. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applanim.2018.05.010